Can Haley Reinhart survive the criticism she received last night? Will Idol voters finally rally behind a female contestant? Or will she become the sixth straight girl voted off Idol, further proving the gender problem executive producer Nigel Lythgoe would like to pretend doesn’t exist? After Pia’s elimination last week, Nigel said Idol viewers will…
Any hope that the Idol judges would wake from their season-long slumber after the ouster of Pia Toscano was shattered midway through Wednesday’s show. Scotty McCreery had just done what Scotty McCreery does every week. Sing a country song well. Hit all the notes. Look self-assured on stage. “You know, everybody wants us to be…
For those counting, Steven Tyler’s streak of performances he loved has reached 39. And it doesn’t look like it will end anytime soon. I mean, the guy is making Paula Abdul look like a novice at positive feedback in his rookie year on Idol. Truth be told, the Idols gave the judges plenty of reasons…
