Since no one was cut this week on American Idol and since eight singers will be sent home when the show reconvenes, I’ve decided to re-rank the Top 24.
After all, we got to see each member of the Top 24 perform a solo (albeit brief) and a celebrity duet on the Sunday and Monday shows, and that helped separate some contenders from pretenders.
The top of these rankings will look similar to those I posted last week, though Ava August and Hunter Metts inched up a bit based on their stellar Top 24 rounds performances.
The biggest change is dramatic jumps for Cassandra Coleman and Beane, both of whom handled Idol’s big stage much better than I expected.
Remember, 16 singers advance to the next round.
Here are the new rankings. The number in parenthesis behind each singer’s name is where they were originally ranked.
See also
Song by song grades for Sunday’s performances on Idol
Song by song grades for Monday’s performances on Idol
1. Chayce Beckham (1), 24, Apple Valley, Calif.
2. Ava August (3), 15, Orange County, Calif.
3. Hunter Metts (4), 22, Franklin, Tenn.
4. Alanis Sophia (2), 19, Dade City, Fla.
5. Alyssa Wray (7), 18, Perryville, Kentucky
6. Jason Warrior (5), 25, Chicago, Ill.
7. Madison Watkins (6), 25, Fayetteville, Ark.
8. Cassandra Coleman (19), 24, Columbia, Tenn.
9. Grace Kinstler (8), 20, Chicago, Ill.
10. Beane (17), 23, Boston, Mass.
11. Mary Jo Young (11), 19, Cleveland, Ohio
12. Deshawn Goncalves (9), 19, Cleveland, Ohio
13. Willie Spence (13), 21, Douglas, Ga.
14. Anilee List (18), 20, Los Angeles
15. Andrea Valles (14), 23, Houston, Texas
16. Alana (Sherman) (12)
17. Wyatt Pike (21), 19, Park City, Utah
18. Liahona Olayan (10), 16, Wahiawa, Hawaii
19. Casey Bishop (16), 15, Estero, Fla.
20. Graham DeFranco (20), 27, Rockwall, Texas
21. Hannah Everhart (22), 17, Canton, Miss.
22. Caleb Kennedy (15), 16, Roebuck, S.C.
23. Colin Jamieson (23), 22,, Boxford, Mass.
24. Cecil Ray (24), 20, Cameron, Texas
Alana Alanis Sophia Alyssa Wray American Idol American Idol Top 24 Andrea Valles Anilee List Ava August Beane Caleb Kennedy Casey Bishop Cassandra Coleman Cecil Ray Chayce Beckham Colin Jamieson Deshawn Goncalves Grace Kinstler Graham DeFranco Hannah Everhart Hunter Metts Jason Warrior Madison Watkins Mary Jo Young Willie Spence Wyatt Pike
Related Posts
-
March 29, 2025 -
-
March 29, 2025 Meet Sarah Day of American Idol Season 23
2 Comments
From the IdolPad spoiler website.
Advanced:
Alanis Sophia
Alyssa Wray
Ava August
Beane
Caleb Kennedy
Casey Bishop
Cassandra Coleman
Chayce Beckham
Colin Jamieson
DeShawn Goncalves
Grace Kinstler
Graham DeFranco
Hunter Metts
Madison Watkins
Willie Spence
Wyatt Pike
Eliminated:
Alana Sherman
Andrea Valles
Anilee List
Cecil Ray
Hannah Everhart
Jason Warrior
Liahona Olayan
Mary Jo Young
Ava August stole the show. She was magical. I agree with your top 2 rankings.